Samsung Galaxy 5 vs Samsung Galaxy S I9000

Who wins: Samsung Galaxy 5 or Samsung Galaxy S I9000?

Choose the Samsung Galaxy S I9000 first unless pocketability and minimal weight are the sole overriding priorities.

Based on our analysis across 5 dimensions with 20 sources, Samsung Galaxy 5 scores 3.9/10 overall while Samsung Galaxy S I9000 scores 8.7/10 overall.

Should I choose Samsung Galaxy 5 or Samsung Galaxy S I9000?

Verdict: Choose the Samsung Galaxy S I9000 first unless pocketability and minimal weight are the sole overriding priorities.

The Samsung Galaxy S I9000 is the superior choice overall, outclassing the Samsung Galaxy 5 in display quality, processing performance, camera capabilities, and storage capacity.

The Samsung Galaxy S I9000 substantially outperforms the Samsung Galaxy 5 across all critical performance metrics. It provides a vastly superior visual experience with a 4.0-inch Super AMOLED display running at 480x800 pixels compared to the Galaxy 5's 2.8-inch 240x320 LCD. Under the hood, the Galaxy S I9000 delivers 67% higher clock speeds and double the memory with its 1.0 GHz Hummingbird CPU and 512 MB of RAM against the Galaxy 5's 600 MHz processor and 256 MB of RAM. Storage is vastly more capable on the Galaxy S I9000 with 8 GB or 16 GB of internal flash memory expandable up to 32 GB, compared to just 512 MB ROM (around 170 MB user-accessible) expandable to 16 GB on the Galaxy 5. Imaging is also significantly advanced on the Galaxy S I9000, offering a 5.0 MP autofocus sensor capable of 720p HD video capture at 30 fps alongside a front VGA camera, whereas the Galaxy 5 relies on a 2.0 MP fixed-focus camera limited to QVGA recording at 15 fps. The Samsung Galaxy 5 is only preferable for users seeking an ultra-compact 102g footprint over the Galaxy S I9000's 119g body and larger 1,500 mAh battery.

Best for Samsung Galaxy 5

• Users prioritizing an ultra-compact and lightweight 102g chassis
• Basic smartphone utility requiring simple calling, texting, and entry-level app access
• One-handed usability on a small 2.8-inch form factor

Best for Samsung Galaxy S I9000

• Vibrant multimedia consumption on a 4.0-inch Super AMOLED 480x800 display
• Demanding apps and multitasking powered by a 1.0 GHz processor and 512 MB RAM
• Extensive onboard media storage with 8 GB or 16 GB internal flash memory
• High-quality photography and 720p HD video recording at 30 fps via a 5.0 MP autofocus camera
• Longer operational endurance backed by a 1,500 mAh battery capacity
• Video calling via a dedicated front VGA camera

When not to compare directly

Do not compare them directly if evaluating strictly by market tier, as the Samsung Galaxy 5 is an entry-level compact device while the Samsung Galaxy S I9000 is a high-end flagship.

What are the key differences between Samsung Galaxy 5 and Samsung Galaxy S I9000?

• Display Size and Panel Technology

  The Samsung Galaxy S I9000 features a larger and much sharper 4.0-inch Super AMOLED screen with a 480x800 resolution, compared to the Samsung Galaxy 5's modest 2.8-inch 240x320 LCD panel.

  Samsung Galaxy 5: The Samsung Galaxy 5 features a compact 2.8-inch TFT LCD display with a resolution of 240x320 pixels (QVGA), offering basic visual output and touch interaction.

  Samsung Galaxy S I9000: The Samsung Galaxy S I9000 delivers a superior viewing experience with its 4.0-inch Super AMOLED display running at a sharper 480x800 pixels (WVGA) resolution.

  Scores — Samsung Galaxy 5: 3.5/10, Samsung Galaxy S I9000: 9/10

  Screen real estate, resolution, and panel quality determine multimedia viewing, web browsing readability, and overall touch interaction.

  Sources: Specifications, Samsung Galaxy 5

• Processing Performance and Memory

  The Samsung Galaxy S I9000 provides superior processing and multitasking performance with its 1.0 GHz Hummingbird processor and 512 MB RAM compared to the Samsung Galaxy 5's 600 MHz processor and 256 MB RAM.

  Samsung Galaxy 5: The Samsung Galaxy 5 is equipped with an entry-level 600 MHz Qualcomm MSM7227 processor paired with 256 MB of RAM, limiting its capacity for multitasking and intensive 3D graphic rendering.

  Samsung Galaxy S I9000: The Samsung Galaxy S I9000 features a flagship 1.0 GHz Hummingbird application processor with a PowerVR SGX540 GPU and 512 MB of RAM, delivering significantly smoother UI performance and superior multimedia processing.

  Scores — Samsung Galaxy 5: 4/10, Samsung Galaxy S I9000: 9/10

  CPU clock speed, GPU capability, and RAM dictate application performance, UI smoothness, and multitasking potential.

  Sources: Specifications, Samsung GT-i5500 Galaxy 5 / Corby Smartphone

• Internal and Expandable Storage

  While the Samsung Galaxy 5 provides only 512 MB of internal ROM with up to 16 GB microSD expansion, the Samsung Galaxy S I9000 offers substantial 8 GB or 16 GB internal flash storage and supports expansion up to 32 GB.

  Samsung Galaxy 5: The Samsung Galaxy 5 comes equipped with a limited 512 MB Flash ROM (around 170 MB user-accessible storage) alongside a microSD/microSDHC slot supporting expansion up to 16 GB.

  Samsung Galaxy S I9000: The Samsung Galaxy S I9000 provides significantly larger built-in internal flash storage capacities of 8 GB or 16 GB, along with a dedicated microSD/microSDHC slot expandable up to 32 GB.

  Scores — Samsung Galaxy 5: 2.5/10, Samsung Galaxy S I9000: 8.5/10

  Onboard storage determines how many apps, media files, and offline assets can be stored directly on the device.

  Sources: Specifications, Samsung Galaxy 5

• Camera Hardware and Video Recording

  The Samsung Galaxy S I9000 outperforms the Samsung Galaxy 5 by offering a 5.0 MP autofocus camera with 720p HD video recording and a front VGA sensor, compared to the Galaxy 5's fixed-focus 2.0 MP rear camera and QVGA video capture.

  Samsung Galaxy 5: The Samsung Galaxy 5 is equipped with a basic fixed-focus 2.0 MP rear camera with no front-facing camera, offering only low-resolution QVGA video recording at 15 fps.

  Samsung Galaxy S I9000: The Samsung Galaxy S I9000 features a superior 5.0 MP autofocus rear camera capable of 720p HD video recording at 30 fps, along with a front VGA camera for video calls.

  Scores — Samsung Galaxy 5: 2.5/10, Samsung Galaxy S I9000: 8.5/10

  Camera sensor resolution, autofocus support, and video capture quality define the device's multimedia content creation abilities.

  Sources: Specifications, Samsung Galaxy 5

• Form Factor and Battery Capacity

  While the Samsung Galaxy 5 offers a lighter 102g build, the Samsung Galaxy S I9000 provides greater operational endurance with its larger 1,500 mAh battery capacity compared to the Galaxy 5's 1,200 mAh cell.

  Samsung Galaxy 5: The Samsung Galaxy 5 features a lightweight 102g compact chassis measuring 108 x 56 x 12.3 mm, powered by a removable 1,200 mAh battery.

  Samsung Galaxy S I9000: The Samsung Galaxy S I9000 offers a larger footprint measuring 122.4 x 64.2 x 9.9 mm and weighing 119g, equipped with a higher-capacity 1,500 mAh battery.

  Scores — Samsung Galaxy 5: 6.8/10, Samsung Galaxy S I9000: 8.5/10

  Physical dimensions, weight, and battery size impact daily pocketability, ergonomics, and operational endurance.

  Sources: Specifications, Samsung Galaxy 5

What are the pros and cons of Samsung Galaxy 5 vs Samsung Galaxy S I9000?

Where does this data come from?

1. SamsungGT-I5500 photo and specification
2. 三星Galaxy S(I9000/8GB)
3. Samsung i5500
4. Specifications
5. Samsung GT-i5500 Galaxy 5 / Corby Smartphone
6. Samsung I9000 Galaxy S
7. Samsung GT-i5500 Galaxy 5 / Corby Smartphone Full Device Specifications
8. 三星 i9000/Sphone
9. Samsung Galaxy 5
10. 三星 I9000 Galaxy S(8GB)
11. Samsung GT-i5500 Galaxy 5 / Corby Smartphone
12. 三星I9000 Galaxy S 8GB3
13. Samsung i5500
14. Samsung Galaxy S (1st generation) - Wikipedia
15. Samsung GT-i5500 Galaxy 5 / Corby Smartphone
16. Samsung Galaxy S Launches with Industry-leading Technological Innovations
17. Samsung Galaxy 5
18. 三星Galaxy S i9000
19. Samsung GT-i5500 Galaxy 5 Corby Smartphone, Galaxy Europa, Samsung GT-i5500 5 手机技术数据 :: GSMchoice.com
20. 三星Galaxy S

Create your own comparison